Re: [討論] Glen Ord 12YO，Glen Elgin 12YO以及Be …

看板Wine (酒板)作者loser1 (馬步軍都知兵馬使)時間18年前 (2008/06/03 02:46)推噓3(3推 0噓 6→)

留言9則, 2人參與討論串1/1

※ 引述《magicshow (寒夜飲美酒)》之銘言： : 如題。不知道有沒有版友喝過這三款酒呢？可以發表一下飲後心得嗎？ : Glen Ord 和 Glen elgin 是不是值得一嚐呢？ : Ben Riach 和阿貝10年相比，何者較優呢？我看過 Jim Murry 給 Glen Ord 的評語:「ZZZzzzzz....」 http://www.whiskymag.com/whisky/brand/glen_ord/whisky58.html Glen Ord 12 Years Old Brand Glen Ord Expression 12 Years Old Type Scotch Whisky / Single Malt Age 12 Year Old Abv 40.00% Produced at Glen Ord Distillery Region Highland Launched 1838 Availability UK, Europe Guide Price ￡11-￡17 (US$18-US$29) Website http://www.malts.com Michael Jackson 7 3/4 Nose Nice touch of sherry to round its big maltiness-and a subtle hint of peat. Palate Luscious, clean, maltiness and barley-sugar sweetness. Moving to drier maltiness and, again, gentle peating. Finish Firm, smooth. Orange zest. Cinnamon. Late, light ginger. Comment Anyone not quite understanding the term "malt" should try this whisky. All will then be clear. Jim Murray Nose Seriously unimpressive: sub-standard sherry notes topped only by a hint of smoke. Pretty grim. Palate Silky but otherwise bland. Very little emerges beyond the flavourless sherry except a brief, malty, smoky peat. Finish Caramel and vanilla. Otherwise dead. Comment Zzzzzzzzzzz. 這是 43度的版本的酒評 http://www.whiskymag.com/whisky/brand/glen_ord/whisky4446.html Glen Ord 12 Years Old Brand Glen Ord Expression 12 Years Old Type Scotch Whisky / Single Malt Age 12 Year Old Abv 43.00% Produced at Glen Ord Distillery Region Highland Launched 1838 Guide Price ￡11-￡17 (US$18-US$29) Website http://www.malts.com Michael Jackson Nose Rich maltiness. Some sherry. Palate Clean, firm, nutty, toasty. Becoming marshmallowy. A hint of ginger. Finish Silky. Smoky. A well-judged touch of peaty dryness. Comment I have long had a sneaking feeling that this malt was underrated. It is: based on my first tasting of the day, in April, 2003. Dave Broom Nose Very malty (Weetabix) medium-bodied with light oak and a mossiness/fresh-turned sod note. With water, there’s coconut pulp, orange, nougat. Palate Dry, crisp and quite oaky. Some light honey, and orange again alongside maltiness. Finish Dry, short but appetising. Comment A good, solid all-rounder. Glen Elgin 看起來很土，當時沒有買。 Ben Riach 舊包裝我有掃光旭亨的記錄，當時一瓶 800 塊。 Ben Riach 的特色是終感無甜味，有花香，典型的 Speyside 的風味，跟 Ardbeg 10 年的煙燻味相比，你要說那個比較好? 我只能說你應該各買一瓶自己比較。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 61.230.177.132 ※ 編輯: loser1 來自: 61.230.177.132 (06/03 02:54)